• Elton Gallegly

    Representative Elton Gallegly: Congress Must Focus on Job Creation and Not Job Killing

    Obama Kisses Nancy Reagan

    Nancy Reagan, President Barack Obama, Senator Richard Lugar (R- Indiana) and Representative Elton Gallegly (R-Simi Valley)

    From the press release:

    “The unemployment numbers released today underscores what I have been saying for months – Congress should be focusing on real job-creation legislation. It should be Congress’s most important domestic priority right now,” said U.S. Rep. Elton Gallegly (R-Ventura & Santa Barbara Counties).

    According to the U.S. Department of Labor, the national unemployment rate reached 10.2 percent in October, the highest rate since 1983.

    “I voted against the trillion-dollar stimulus bill in February because it was unfocused and spent more on social programs than job creation. Unfortunately for the American people, I have been proven right. Unemployment was 7.9 percent nationally when President Obama signed the bill in February. It’s now 10.2 percent and growing. Very few jobs were created by the stimulus, as reflected in today’s unemployment numbers.

    “Of those jobs that were created, more than half are government, not private sector, jobs. That means more deficit spending or higher taxes to cover government payrolls with no goods or services created to stimulate the economy. Likewise, the health care and cap and trade bills being pushed by House Speaker Nancy Pelosi will destroy millions of more jobs through burdensome and unnecessary regulations on small businesses and higher taxes on businesses and the American people.

    “We can and must do better.

    “I supported a stimulus package that actually would have created jobs by giving small businesses—which employ half of all Americans—the incentives to innovate and expand, thereby producing new jobs. Congress should repeal the stimulus package passed in February and pass this bill now.

    “I supported an energy bill that would have created more jobs and enhanced our national security by expanding energy production in all areas—including wind, solar, nuclear and natural gas. I urge Speaker Pelosi to allow a vote on this bill.

    “I support a healthcare plan that does no harm by opening up competition and reining in frivolous lawsuits and which helps the working poor and those with preexisting conditions to obtain coverage. Again, I urge the speaker to rescind her $1.3 trillion healthcare bill and push for real reform that creates, not destroys, jobs.”

    As an aside for Ventura County, California political observers: Elton Gallegly is NOT retiring and running for re-election in 2010.


    Technorati Tags:

  • Elton Gallegly,  Ronald Reagan

    Representative Elton Gallegly Appointed to Commission Honoring President Ronald Reagan

    Gallegly and Wexler

    Congressman Robert Wexler (D- Florida) and Elton Gallegly (R-Simi Valley, California), ranking member of the House Subcommittee on Europe talking with Foreign Minister Markos Kyprianou of the European Union

    From the Press Release:

    U.S. Rep. Elton Gallegly (R-CA) was appointed to the Ronald Reagan Centennial Commission today by House Minority Leader John Boehner of Ohio.

    Gallegly authored the bill that created the commission and is the second person assigned to the 11-member commission. Secretary of Interior Ken Salazar was named to the commission in the bill.

    “Elton Gallegly was instrumental to the creation of this commission and it’s terrific that he’ll be actively involved in the celebration of Ronald Reagan’s centennial,” said Frederick J. Ryan, Jr., Chairman of the Board of Trustees of the Ronald Reagan Presidential Foundation.

    The 11-member Ronald Reagan Centennial Commission Act will plan and carry out activities deemed fitting to honor Ronald Reagan on his 100th birthday, which falls on Feb. 6, 2011.

     â€œI appreciate Leader Boehner’s appointment,” Gallegly said. “I look forward to working with my fellow commissioners to create appropriate activities to honor President Reagan and to celebrate his life and accomplishments on behalf of the country he loved.”

    The commission will make recommendations and provide necessary assistance for federal, state and local governmental agencies and civic groups to honor President Reagan. Such activities could include special stamps or coins. In addition, the commission will recommend to Congress activities to honor his 100th birthday, including the possible convening of a Joint Session of Congress.

    In addition to Gallegly and Secretary Salazar, nine more members need to be appointed: President Obama will appoint four members; House Speaker Nancy Pelosi will appoint two; Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid will appoint two; and Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell will appoint one. They have 90 days from enactment of the bill to make their appointments.

    No federal money can be spent on the commission or its activities.

    Gallegly’s bill attracted wide bipartisan support. The Senate passed the bill by unanimous consent on May 20 and the House passed it on a 371-19 vote on March 9. President Obama signed Gallegly’s bill during a June 2 White House ceremony attended by Gallegly and former First Lady Nancy Reagan.

    Previous commissions have been instituted to honor Presidents Franklin D. Roosevelt, Harry Truman and Abraham Lincoln.

    The Ronald Reagan Presidential Library and Museum is in Simi Valley, CA, Gallegly’s hometown.

    I am looking forward to next year’s event at the Reagan Library. A gathering of conservatives, young and old, the world has probably never seen before.

    Stay tuned…….


    Technorati Tags: ,

  • Barack Obama,  Elton Gallegly,  Nancy Reagan,  Ronald Reagan

    Video: Nancy Reagan to President Obama at U. S. Representative Elton Gallegly Bill Signing – “Oh, You’re a LEFTY”

    President Barack Obama, seated, joined by former first lady Nancy Reagan, left, and others, signs the Ronald Reagan Centennial Commission Act during a ceremony in the Diplomatic Reception Room of the White House in Washington, Tuesday, June 2, 2009. From left are, Nancy Reagan, Rep. Dana Rohrabacher, R-Calif., the president, Sen. Richard Lugar, R-Ind., Rep. Elton Gallegly, R-Calif., and Rep. Bill Foster, D-Ill.

    This is hilarious and oh so TRUE.

    President Obama is a LEFTY.


    Technorati Tags: , , ,

  • Barack Obama,  Elton Gallegly,  Nancy Reagan,  Ronald Reagan

    President Obama Signs U.S. Representative Elton Gallegly’s Bill Honoring President Ronald Reagan

    Obama Reagan

    President Barack Obama, seated, joined by former first lady Nancy Reagan, left, and others, signs the Ronald Reagan Centennial Commission Act during a ceremony in the Diplomatic Reception Room of the White House in Washington, Tuesday, June 2, 2009. From left are, Nancy Reagan, Rep. Dana Rohrabacher, R-Calif., the president, Sen. Richard Lugar, R-Ind., Rep. Elton Gallegly, R-Calif., and Rep. Bill Foster, D-Ill.

    From the Press Release:

    In a White House ceremony attended by former first lady Nancy Reagan and U.S. Rep. Elton Gallegly (R-Ventura & Santa Barbara Counties), President Obama today signed Gallegly’s bill to honor President Ronald Reagan on the 100th anniversary of his birth.

    The Ronald Reagan Centennial Commission Act creates an 11-member commission that will plan and carry out activities deemed fitting to honor Ronald Reagan on his 100th birthday, which falls on Feb. 6, 2011.

    The commission will make recommendations and provide necessary assistance for federal, state and local governmental agencies and civic groups to honor President Reagan’s 100th birthday. Such activities could include special stamps or coins. In addition, the commission will recommend to Congress activities to honor President Reagan’s 100th birthday, including the possible convening of a Joint Session of Congress.

    No federal money can be spent on the commission or its activities.

    “Having Mrs. Reagan at the bill signing gave it special significance,” Gallegly said. “She was President Reagan’s staunchest supporter before, during and after his presidency. I appreciate that President Obama scheduled the ceremony so that she could attend.”

    Mrs. Reagan will also attend the unveiling of President Reagan’s statue in the U.S. Capitol Rotunda on Wednesday.

    Gallegly’s bill attracted wide bipartisan support. The Senate passed the bill by unanimous consent on May 20 and the House passed it on a 371-19 vote on March 9.

    Obama and Nancy Reagan walking

    From left to right, Mrs. Reagan, President Obama, Rep. Dana Rohrabacher (R-CA), Elton, U.S. Sen. Richard Lugar (R-IN) and Rep. Bill Foster (D-IL).

    Obama Kisses Nancy Reagan

    President Barack Obama kisses former First Lady Nancy Reagan after signing the Ronald Reagan Centennial Commission Act June 2, 2009

    What a nice gesture by President Obama to honor President Ronald Reagan and have a White House bill signing ceremony for Nancy.

    And, thanks to Flap’s Congressman Elton Gallegly for sponsoring the bill in the House.

    Now, this is bipartisanship and makes me proud, especially since the Ronald Reagan Presidential Library and Museum is just a few miles from where I live.
    Obama and Nancy Reagan closeup


    Technorati Tags: , , ,

  • Elton Gallegly,  Ronald Reagan

    United States Senate Passes Rep. Elton Gallegly Bill Honoring President Ronald Reagan

    ronald reagan

    From the press release:

    The U.S. Senate late Tuesday passed a bill by U.S. Rep. Elton Gallegly (R-Ventura & Santa Barbara Counties) to honor President Ronald Reagan on the 100th anniversary of his birth.

    The Senate passed the bill by unanimous consent. On March 9, the House passed it on a 371-19 vote, with one Member voting present. The bill now goes to President Obama for his signature.

    The Ronald Reagan Centennial Commission Act will create an 11-member commission that will plan and carry out activities deemed fitting to honor Ronald Reagan on his 100th birthday, which will be on Feb. 6, 2011.

    The commission will make recommendations and provide necessary assistance for federal, state and local governmental agencies and civic groups to honor President Reagan’s 100th birthday. Such activities could include special stamps or coins. In addition, the commission will recommend to Congress activities to honor President Reagan’s 100th birthday, including the possible convening of a Joint Session of Congress.

    No federal money can be spent on the commission or its activities.

    “The bipartisan support for the commission says a lot about how President Reagan’s impact on U.S. and international affairs continues to be felt today,” Gallegly said. “President Reagan inspired greatness in the nation he loved. Celebrating his life and accomplishments is a celebration of America.”

    Gallegly also noted that it’s fitting that the legislation passed in time for the unveiling of President Reagan’s statue in the U.S. Capitol Rotunda on June 3. Former first lady Nancy Reagan will attend the ceremony.

    Flap will be looking forward to the festivities next February 6th at the Reagan Presidential Library in Simi Valley, California.


    Technorati Tags: ,

  • Elton Gallegly,  Ronald Reagan,  Russ Feingold

    Senator Russ Feingold Blocks Rep. Elton Gallegly’s Sponsored Bill Honoring President Ronald Reagan Updated

    +++++Updated+++++

    Flap just received notice from DC that Senator Russ Feingold is releasing his hold on this bill because it means so much to Mrs. Nancy Reagan.

    Why Feingold had the gall to place a hold in the first place is beyond belief. But, the hold is lifted and let the celebrations begin on the anniversary of the Gippers birthday 100 years ago this coming February.

    ronald reagan

    The 40th President of the United States Ronald Wilson Reagan

    Roll Call has a piece today about Senator Russ Feingold, D-Wisconsin, blocking in the United States Senate ,Flap’s Congressman Elton Gallegly’s bill honoring President Ronald Reagan on the 100th anniversary of his birth.

    The House of Representatives today passed a bill by Congressman Elton Gallegly (R-Ventura & Santa Barbara Counties) to honor President Ronald Reagan on the 100th anniversary of his birth.

    The bill passed on a 371-19 vote, with one Member voting present.

    The Ronald Reagan Centennial Commission Act would create an 11-member commission that will plan and carry out activities deemed fitting to honor Ronald Reagan on his 100th birthday, which will be on Feb. 6, 2011.

    The commission will make recommendations and provide necessary assistance for federal, state and local governmental agencies and civic groups to honor Reagan’s 100th birthday. Such activities could include special stamps or coins. In addition, the commission will recommend to Congress activities to honor Reagan’s 100th birthday, including the possible convening of a Joint Session of Congress.

    No federal money can be spent on the commission or its activities.

    “‘The Great Communicator’ spoke for the American people, capturing the hearts of small-town citizens and world leaders alike,” Gallegly told his colleagues before the vote today. “California enjoyed an economic resurgence during his terms as governor, and as President of the United States his legacy is extraordinary: In eight short years as President, Ronald Reagan presided over international changes and ushered in unparalleled peace and prosperity—not only for our nation, but for the world.”

    The Ronald Reagan Presidential Library and Museum is in Simi Valley, CA, Gallegly’s hometown.

    Previous commissions have been instituted to honor Presidents Franklin D. Roosevelt, Harry Truman and Abraham Lincoln.

    The bill, H.R. 131 can be found here.

    So, why is Democrat Senator Feingold blocking the bill or better yet holding the bill hostage?

    Politics – Feingold wants to drive his own agenda and amend a non-controversial bill.

    Republicans are trying to pass legislation in the next few weeks to kick off the commemoration of the 100th anniversary of Ronald Reagan’s birth, and the only hurdle appears to be Sen. Russ Feingold (D-Wis.), who is refusing to let the Senate vote on the bill.

    Feingold’s decision to block passage of a bipartisan commission to celebrate the former president’s 100th birthday has nothing to do with antagonism toward the conservative icon. But he does want to use the momentum behind the bill to drive legislation of his own.

    “Sen. Feingold has no interest in blocking this bill,” said a Feingold spokesman, referring to the Ronald Reagan Centennial Commission Act. “He wants to offer an amendment to it, but that request was blocked by a Republican Senator.”

    Feingold’s amendment would establish two commissions to study the internment and restrictions of German and Italian Americans and Jewish refugees during World War II, and it is unrelated to the Reagan bill. The Reagan measure would establish a commission to plan federal and state celebrations around Reagan’s centennial birthday in February 2011.

    Feingold’s spokesman said that the noncontroversial bill would be a good vehicle for the internment amendment, which he said is also noncontroversial.

    Supporters of the Reagan commission question Feingold’s motives for blocking a bill that passed the House 371-19 on March 9.

    Ryan Patmintra, a spokesman for Sen. Jon Kyl (R-Ariz.), said if Feingold’s amendment is truly noncontroversial, he should simply go through the regular committee process and move it to the Senate floor.

    “It should have no problem passing through the Judiciary Committee where Democrats have a 12-seat majority,” Patmintra said. “Sen. Feingold has decided to hold this bill hostage using his own” amendment.
    On May 11, Kyl rejected a request by Sen. Chris Dodd (D-Conn.) on behalf of Feingold to attach the Wartime Treatment Study Act to the Reagan commission bill.

    A GOP aide said some Senate Democrats were not comfortable with Feingold’s amendment.

    “That’s why he wants to attach it. [The Reagan bill] is a commission that everybody supports,” the aide said.

    Representative Gallegly is not pleased.

    Rep. Elton Gallegly (R-Calif.), the bill’s lead sponsor in the House, said the commission’s funding has been restructured and that private donors have been found to pay for the Reagan tributes, which are likely to cost millions of dollars. 

    “I didn’t question their motives,” Gallegly said. “We got all the funding struck from it and passed it out of committee with overwhelming support.” 

    He added, “In a matter of a week we got 140 co-sponsors.” 

    Gallegly said he had hoped to have the legislation passed in time for the unveiling of Reagan’s statue in the Rotunda on June 3, since former first lady Nancy Reagan will be attending the ceremony. 

    Gallegly said it would be a shame “to have her here and not to be able to do these things concurrently [because] of folly about what should be simple.” 

    Clearly, this is grandstanding partisan politics by Feingold.

    The left-wing Democrat Senator should really cut the crap, unblock the bill and move on to moving his own bill forward.


    Technorati Tags: , ,

  • Elton Gallegly,  Ronald Reagan,  Russ Feingold

    Senator Russ Feingold Blocks Rep. Elton Gallegly’s Sponsored Bill Honoring President Ronald Reagan

    ronald reagan

    The 40th President of the United States Ronald Wilson Reagan

    Roll Call has a piece today about Senator Russ Feingold, D-Wisconsin, blocking in the United States Senate ,Flap’s Congressman Elton Gallegly’s bill honoring President Ronald Reagan on the 100th anniversary of his birth.

    The House of Representatives today passed a bill by Congressman Elton Gallegly (R-Ventura & Santa Barbara Counties) to honor President Ronald Reagan on the 100th anniversary of his birth.

    The bill passed on a 371-19 vote, with one Member voting present.

    The Ronald Reagan Centennial Commission Act would create an 11-member commission that will plan and carry out activities deemed fitting to honor Ronald Reagan on his 100th birthday, which will be on Feb. 6, 2011.

    The commission will make recommendations and provide necessary assistance for federal, state and local governmental agencies and civic groups to honor Reagan’s 100th birthday. Such activities could include special stamps or coins. In addition, the commission will recommend to Congress activities to honor Reagan’s 100th birthday, including the possible convening of a Joint Session of Congress.

    No federal money can be spent on the commission or its activities.

    “‘The Great Communicator’ spoke for the American people, capturing the hearts of small-town citizens and world leaders alike,” Gallegly told his colleagues before the vote today. “California enjoyed an economic resurgence during his terms as governor, and as President of the United States his legacy is extraordinary: In eight short years as President, Ronald Reagan presided over international changes and ushered in unparalleled peace and prosperity—not only for our nation, but for the world.”

    The Ronald Reagan Presidential Library and Museum is in Simi Valley, CA, Gallegly’s hometown.

    Previous commissions have been instituted to honor Presidents Franklin D. Roosevelt, Harry Truman and Abraham Lincoln.

    The bill, H.R. 131 can be found here.

    So, why is Democrat Senator Feingold blocking the bill or better yet holding the bill hostage?

    Politics – Feingold wants to drive his own agenda and amend a non-controversial bill.

    Republicans are trying to pass legislation in the next few weeks to kick off the commemoration of the 100th anniversary of Ronald Reagan’s birth, and the only hurdle appears to be Sen. Russ Feingold (D-Wis.), who is refusing to let the Senate vote on the bill.

    Feingold’s decision to block passage of a bipartisan commission to celebrate the former president’s 100th birthday has nothing to do with antagonism toward the conservative icon. But he does want to use the momentum behind the bill to drive legislation of his own.

    “Sen. Feingold has no interest in blocking this bill,” said a Feingold spokesman, referring to the Ronald Reagan Centennial Commission Act. “He wants to offer an amendment to it, but that request was blocked by a Republican Senator.”

    Feingold’s amendment would establish two commissions to study the internment and restrictions of German and Italian Americans and Jewish refugees during World War II, and it is unrelated to the Reagan bill. The Reagan measure would establish a commission to plan federal and state celebrations around Reagan’s centennial birthday in February 2011.

    Feingold’s spokesman said that the noncontroversial bill would be a good vehicle for the internment amendment, which he said is also noncontroversial.

    Supporters of the Reagan commission question Feingold’s motives for blocking a bill that passed the House 371-19 on March 9.

    Ryan Patmintra, a spokesman for Sen. Jon Kyl (R-Ariz.), said if Feingold’s amendment is truly noncontroversial, he should simply go through the regular committee process and move it to the Senate floor.

    “It should have no problem passing through the Judiciary Committee where Democrats have a 12-seat majority,” Patmintra said. “Sen. Feingold has decided to hold this bill hostage using his own” amendment.
    On May 11, Kyl rejected a request by Sen. Chris Dodd (D-Conn.) on behalf of Feingold to attach the Wartime Treatment Study Act to the Reagan commission bill.

    A GOP aide said some Senate Democrats were not comfortable with Feingold’s amendment.

    “That’s why he wants to attach it. [The Reagan bill] is a commission that everybody supports,” the aide said.

    Representative Gallegly is not pleased.

    Rep. Elton Gallegly (R-Calif.), the bill’s lead sponsor in the House, said the commission’s funding has been restructured and that private donors have been found to pay for the Reagan tributes, which are likely to cost millions of dollars. 

    “I didn’t question their motives,” Gallegly said. “We got all the funding struck from it and passed it out of committee with overwhelming support.” 

    He added, “In a matter of a week we got 140 co-sponsors.” 

    Gallegly said he had hoped to have the legislation passed in time for the unveiling of Reagan’s statue in the Rotunda on June 3, since former first lady Nancy Reagan will be attending the ceremony. 

    Gallegly said it would be a shame “to have her here and not to be able to do these things concurrently [because] of folly about what should be simple.” 

    Clearly, this is grandstanding partisan politics by Feingold.

    The left-wing Democrat Senator should really cut the crap, unblock the bill and move on to moving his own bill forward.


    Technorati Tags: , ,

  • Democrats,  Elton Gallegly,  GOP

    Believe It Or Not: The GOP is NOT a Regional Party

    gop-regional-party-2

    The LEFT and Democrats like to portray the GOP as a regional only party but it just NOT so. Look at the map above of the Obama victory over McCain just a few months ago.

    Jim Geraghty does the analysis.

    Discussing the 2010 elections for the House of Representatives with David Freddoso and Mark Hemingway earlier today, we noticed that the “the Republican Party is becoming a regional party” argument is nonsense — even though it’s widely repeated.

    The AP, today: “With Sen. Arlen Specter’s switch to the Democrats, the Republican Party is increasingly at risk of being viewed as a mostly Southern and solidly conservative party, an identity that might take years to overcome.”

    Er, no. The South amounts to 44 percent of the Republican House delegation, which means 56 percent has to come from somewhere else.

    And that’s just looking at House districts. Examine these charts from CQ. McCain won 193 of the nation’s 435 congressional districts, including 49 that split their tickets to elect Democrats to the U.S. House. There are currently 178 Republicans in the House of Representatives. So a total of 227 House districts voted for either McCain, or a Republican House member, or both — in what everyone would agree was a fantastic year for Democrats.

    Even if Republicans won every House seat in the South they would only have 131 seats — leaving 96 other districts across the country.

    Even in their shrunken minority, Republicans hold 19 House seats in California, eight in Ohio, seven in Michigan, seven in Illinois, seven in Pennsylvania, five in New Jersey, five in Missouri, three in Minnesota, three in New York, three in Washington state, and the one seat in Delaware.

    And it works in the reverse, too — Democrats actually represent more House seats in Arkansas, Tennessee, Mississippi, Virginia and North Carolina than Republicans. Neither party is as regional as conventional wisdom suggests.

    Let’s look at Flap’s Congressional district that was won by Obama last November:

    gop-regional-party-1

    Yet, long-time incumbent GOP Represenative Elton Gallegly won by a comfortable 16 points in a down GOP year.

    The LEFT and Democrats like to blow smoke and hope it catches fire.

    Now, the GOP does have a New York and New England problem but not one that marginalizes the national party.

    Sorry, Democrats.


    Technorati Tags: , ,

  • Animal Cruelty,  Elton Gallegly,  Supreme Court

    U.S. Supreme Court to Review Controversial Ruling Striking Down Federal Animal Cruelty Law

    Elton Gallegly February 2008

    Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert, second left, stands with US Congress members Representative Jane Harman, left, Senator Jon Kyl, center, Representative Elton Gallegly, second right, and Senator Sam Brownback, during their meeting at the Knesset, Israel’s parliament, in Jerusalem, Monday, Feb. 18, 2008

    This bill which outlawed “animal crush” videos was overturned last year by a federal appeals court and was sponsored by Flap’s Congressman, Elton Gallegly. The United Sates Supreme Court today granted review of the case and will do so in the Fall Term of the court.

    The Supreme Court will consider reviving a federal law banning the sale of images of animal cruelty. A federal appeals court said the law illegally restricts this form of free speech.

    The justices said Monday that they will look at the decision by the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Philadelphia that also overturned the conviction of Robert Stevens of Pittsville, Va. In 2005, Stevens was convicted and sentenced to 37 months in prison for selling videos of pit bull fights.

    The appeals court described one video as including a “gruesome depiction of a pit bull attacking the lower jaw of a domestic farm pig.”

    The government says it has a “compelling interest in protecting animals from wanton acts of cruelty.”

    The Humane Society of the United States, backing the government, says that the 1999 law played a critical role in stopping the spread of so-called crush videos that show women crushing to death small animals, often with their bare feet or high-heeled shoes.

    The case will be argued in the fall.

    The case is U.S. v. Stevens, 08-769.

    The United States Supreme Court will decide whether there should be a new exception to the First amendment to apply to the portrayals of animal cruelty.

    The new First Amendment case the Justices will be hearing next fall or winter involves the constitutionality of a 1999 federal law, passed by Congress in an attempt to curb animal cruelty.  The en banc Third Circuit Court struck down the law as written, thus barring its use in any case no matter what the specific facts.

    Although the law has been in effect for ten years, it was used for the first time to prosecute Robert J. Stevens of Pittsville, Va., for selling videotapes of fighting among dogs of the Pit Bull breed.   He was convicted of three counts of violating the 1999 law, and was sentenced to 37 months in prison.

    In nullifying the law, the Circuit Court refused to create a new exception to the First Amendment to apply to portrayals of animal cruelty. It noted that the Supreme Court “last declared an entire category of speech unprotected” by the Amendment in 1982 (in New York v. Ferber, involving child pornography).  The Circuit Court rejected a government argument that the depiction of animal cruelty was analogous to the depiction of child pornography.

    In taking the case on to the Supreme Court, the Justice Department argued that the 1999 law is narrow in scope, applying only to a “particularly harmful class of speech,” only when that is done for commercial gain, and only when the particular depiction has “no serious societal value.”

    It may be a close call for the court, but Flap does not really see any societal value in permitting animal cruelty or “animal crush” videos. As long as the decision is narrow, there should be no danger to our constitutionally protected free speech.

    Stay tuned……


    Technorati Tags: , ,