I oppose the Miers nomination.
The Truth Laid Bear has Call to Bloggers: Take Your Stand on Miers
Flap opposes the Miers nomination.
Captain Ed at Captain’s Quarters has Bad News Turns Into Flood On Miers.
In response, let me say that I have supported Miers’ confirmation up to now, almost exclusively on two bases: presidential prerogative and an assumption of basic competence, both on her part and the White House. The questionnaire has my confidence in the second basis badly shaken. The slapdash manner of its preparation tells me someone isn’t taking this seriously, and since Miers has her name on it, that’s her responsibility. The way she managed to antagonize Specter adds to that impression. She’s striking me as an imprecise and sloppy nominee for a position that requires absolute clarity and precision.
Given that, my reliance on presidential prerogative remains … but it doesn’t outweigh my objection to getting a substandard jurist on the Supreme Court. Waiting until the hearings for her to get exposed as that will prove a political disaster for the President and the GOP. For those reasons, I’d strongly suggest that the White House look for a way out of this, and fast.
Harriet Miers was not Flap’s first choice for nomination to the Unites States Supreme Court. Flap thought President Bush would chose another Texas jurist and former Texas Supreme Court Justice, Priscilla Owen. The President should rethink his choice.
Harriet Miers’ confirmation process is not going well:
1. Numerous petitions against her nomination
2. Numerous mis-steps in the nomination process with blunders with Senate Judiciary Committee Chairman Arlen Specter and then the poorly written/constructed Senate Judiciary Committee Questionnaire
Flap understands that this choice is the President’s perogative.
However, Flap no longer believes Harriet Miers can be confirmed.
The Democrats will not vote for her because of her pro-life evangelical proclivities. John Fund of the Wall Street Journal “outed” a stealth deal on Roe v. Wade.
Republican Senators will be conflicted to vote her out of the Senate Judiciary Committee. She does not need a positive recommendation from the committee but Flap cannot imagine a majority of Senators voting for a nominee who cannot muster a majority committee vote.
So, why go through a brutal hearing process?
Harriet Miers should ask the President withdraw her nomination and she should resume her duties as White House Counsel.
The President should then nominate former Texas Supreme Court Justice Priscilla Owen.
or any of these other fine federal appeals court judges: